RSS Feeds Feeds: Articles | Issues
Articles About TAP Subscribe Donate
TAPPED  |  Beat the Press

Current Issue
SUBSCRIBE | LOGIN

SUBSCRIBER LOG IN:
Remember Me
Forgot your password?
Current Issue
Download the PDF

The symbol identifies content for paid subscribers only.


 



The group blog of The American Prospect

« SENATE STIMULUS CHAT. | Main | LIGHTNING ROUND: CHASING THE BIPARTISAN DRAGON NO MORE. »

MORE CBO HIGH JINKS.

I've got a cottage industry here debunking ridiculous conservative arguments based on faulty readings of Congressional Budget Office reports. Today, the Washington Times is in a tizzy because of a new report requested by Senators Judd Gregg and Chuck Grassley.

The report is pretty straightforward: The stimulus will work in the short term, raising both GDP and employment, but taking on a lot of government debt will result in some crowding-out effect, which by 2019 could lessen GDP by .1 to .3 percent. Essentially, the stimulus will work to alleviate the recession, but long-term debt remains an issue -- it will "reduce output slightly in the long run" -- which basically anyone could tell you. And I think the Obama administration has been pretty clear that after the recession they're going to look to cut deficits and lower that debt; part of that is health-care reform, part of that is some kind of "entitlement reform" (a special Gregg issue) and part of it will be tax reform. But instead of recognizing what basically everybody already knows (that long-term debt is problematic and the government will have to deal with it after the recession), the Times runs with this:

CBO: Obama stimulus harmful over long haul

CBO, the official scorekeepers for legislation, said the House and Senate bills will help in the short term but result in so much government debt that within a few years they would crowd out private investment, actually leading to a lower Gross Domestic Product over the next 10 years than if the government had done nothing.

Love that they don't choose to mention that scale of the lowered productivity. Why explain accurately what you can demagogue? And of course the recession will eventually go away if we do nothing, but the problem is the cost to our productivity, the lives of our citizens, and our international standing.

The agency projected the Senate bill would produce between 1.4 percent and 4.1 percent higher growth in 2009 than if there was no action. For 2010, the plan would boost growth by 1.2 percent to 3.6 percent.

CBO did project the bill would create jobs, though by 2011 the effects would be minuscule.

Well of course, because most of the spending will be completed by 2011 -- it's a temporary bill. Really, this is terrible analysis.

-- Tim Fernholz

Posted by Tim Fernholz on February 5, 2009 4:41 PM | |



COMMENTS (2)

YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.
YOU'RE NOT LIVING IN REALITY.GOP IS DEAD.

Posted by: misfit | February 6, 2009 6:25 AM

God, you too are missing the point!

Please, please, please read this diary:

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2009/2/6/03938/84028/757/693856

The Wa Times article is wrong in a MUCH more fundamental way than what you've pointed out. The CBO calculated the long-run net loss from the *baseline* - in other words, as if the short run effect had NEVER HAPPENED.

The ACTUAL TOTAL NET IMPACT of the stimulus bill is of course positive. But bad CBO wording has allowed the Wa Times to completely screw up their reading of the letter and conclude "worse off than if we did nothing" which is literally false.

It's not 3-6% GDP increase in 2009-2011 and than a 3.1 - 6.3% decrease in 2012-2019 to create a "net" of -0.1 to 0.3. That's ludicrous, when you think about it. There's no effing way $800 billion in debt could shave 6% of GDP off of us through crowding out. That's a two-year depression all by itself!

It's a 3-6% increase in GDP in 2009-2011 followed by a 0.1-0.3 percent loss from maximum in 2012-2019, for a net gain of 2.7 - 5.7%.

BUT THAT'S NOT WHAT THE WASHINGTON TIMES SAYS. Please, please please, for god's sake, rewrite your critique! This is Important!

Posted by: glasnost | February 6, 2009 8:25 AM

Post a comment

Search TAPPED for:

Archives

About TAPPED

TAPPED, the Prospect's award-winning group blog, is a link-intensive collection of musings, ramblings, opinions and other assorted writing on the political developments of the day. See a list of our contributors.

| RSS | Twitter

Blog Roll

Support independent media with a tax-deductible donation.
Renew your print subscription or e-subscription.
Get an e-subscription for $14.95.
Give the gift of political insight. Send The American Prospect to a friend.
Change your email address or street address.
YES! I want to receive The American Prospect
— the essential source for progressive ideas. Explore The American Prospect's award-winning investigative journalism and provocative essays in a free trial issue. Continue receiving The American Prospect at only $19.95 for a one-year subscription - a savings of 60% off the newsstand price!
First Name
Last Name
Address 1
Address 2
City
State
ZIP     
Email

Should you decide not to continue receiving the magazine after the initial free issue, simply write "cancel" on the invoice and you will not be billed.

© 2010 by The American Prospect, Inc.  |  Privacy Policy  |  Permissions and Reprints