YOUR WORLD IN CHARTS: MOST LIBERAL SENATOR?
Electoral-vote.com has done the work to compile a fine list of the Senate's most liberal members, using as a benchmark the aggregate scores from seven independent ranking organizations. On the one hand, each organization tends to focus on one area of policy, which helps analytically separate the senators using a common metric. On the other hand, this process generates a somewhat apples-oranges-pears-bananas -- etc. -- approach that at best gives us a range of liberalism. Hillary Clinton's highest scores are a perfect one from NARAL and 91 percent from the SEIU.
Barack Obama also receives a perfect score from NARAL, about the same scores from the ADA and SEIU a slightly higher one from the ACLU, and somewhat lower on CDF and LCV. This simply confirms what we already know: both Clinton and Obama are virtually indistinguishable on policy. Yet "most liberal" hardly seems right. Using electoral-vote's mean average of these scores, Clinton comes in as the 38th most liberal, Obama the 42nd, which makes them closer to "centrists" I suppose.
Compared to John McCain, however (96th most liberal, or 5th most conservative), they are less extreme. The Votemaster promises a similar chart using data from independent conservative ranking organizations, and we'll revisit this issue again then.
--Mori Dinauer
Feeds: 



COMMENTS (2)
The most "liberal" Senator is whomever gets the nomination. Always.
Posted by: merl | April 10, 2008 9:23 AM
both Clinton and Obama are virtually indistinguishable on policy.
It shows that they make similar votes on the bills that get to the floor. That's different from the policy each would pursue.
Also the two are only indistinguishable with respect to ultraconservative McCain. A rating of 60% versus 70% (from the LCV) seems like it could be pretty significant. And just what were the votes listed by the ACLU that earned Obama a higher ranking than Clinton?
Posted by: Jinchi | April 10, 2008 5:02 PM