GAME ON, RECESSION.
With the news that our economy is now contracting -- for the first time since 1991 -- at .03 percent annually, few could deny that a recession has begun. The hit mainly comes from contracting consumer spending in response to job losses and other economic problems. The candidates used the news to snipe at each other, but neither said anything interesting substantively. I'll include their statements after the jump anyways, because, hey, there's no word limit on the internet, right?
I don't have too much commentary on the announcement itself; we knew the economy was shrinking, now we know by (roughly) how much. The question, as always, is what is to be done? The answer is stimulus. And it's not just me and my liberal pals who think so! No, my friends, it's Martin Feldstein as well. The conservative economist and McCain adviser has stepped into the breach and dealt what is hopefully a death blow to neo-hooverism by writing the following:
Another round of one-time tax rebates won't do the job. The rebates that Congress enacted this spring failed to stimulate consumer spending: More than 80 percent of tax rebate dollars were saved or used to pay down existing debt.The only way to prevent a deepening recession will be a temporary program of increased government spending. Previous attempts to use government spending to stimulate an economic recovery, particularly spending on infrastructure, have not been successful because of long legislative lags that delayed the spending until a recovery was well underway. But while past recessions lasted an average of only about 12 months, this downturn is likely to last much longer, providing the scope for successful countercyclical spending.
A fiscal package of $100 billion is not likely to be large enough to revive the economy. The fall in household wealth resulting from the collapse of the stock market and the decline of home prices may cut aggregate spending by $300 billion a year or more.
The president-elect should focus on developing a mechanism for identifying and funding spending initiatives that can occur quickly and that would otherwise not be done. While it would be good if some of the increased spending also contributed to long-term productivity, the key is to stimulate demand. Any plan to finance this spending by raising taxes, even if postponed, as Sen. Barack Obama has suggested, would hurt the recovery by causing affected taxpayers to cut their spending now.
The increased government spending should include not only money for infrastructure such as bridges and roads but also for a wide range of equipment. Rebuilding some of the military capacity that has been depleted by the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan could be done relatively quickly and should be part of the overall package.
-- Tim Fernholz
Today, Doug Holtz-Eakin, McCain-Palin 2008 Senior Policy Adviser, issued the following statement on the Gross Domestic Product (GDP) number:
"Today's announcement that third quarter GDP fell at a 0.3 percent rate confirms what Americans already knew: the economy is shrinking. Barack Obama would accelerate this dangerous course. According to the independent Center for Data Analysis, Barack Obama's new policies will destroy nearly 6 million jobs over the next decade.
"Barack Obama's ideologically-driven plans to redistribute income will impose higher taxes on families, small businesses, and investors; expensive, rigid, job-killing health mandates on employers; energy policies that fail to promote domestic oil, natural gas, and coal, and will impose a massive Washington-driven regulation of everything from home furnaces to factories; isolationist trade policies that endanger one out of every five jobs; and massive new spending plans that that will burden the economy and saddle our children with debt. Barack Obama is change Americans cannot afford.
"John McCain's comprehensive reforms will clean up Wall Street, clean up Washington, and create nearly 2 million more jobs over the same period. John McCain offers a new direction and a real choice: lower taxes and under control spending; lower health care costs and portable insurance; an energy policy that declares independence from dangerous and unstable sources, values the environment, and supports growth; serious reforms to taxes, education, and trade to promote global competitiveness, and short-run plans to help the seniors, savers, homeowners, and workers hurt by the financial crisis."
Below is a statement from Senator Barack Obama on today’s decline in our GDP
“This morning, we learned that GDP has fallen for the first time this year, which means America is producing less and selling less and our economy is shrinking. American consumers were especially hard hit, experiencing their largest decline in spending in 28 years as wages failed to keep up with the rising cost of living. The decline in our GDP didn’t happen by accident – it is a direct result of the Bush Administration's trickle down, Wall Street first, Main Street last policies that John McCain has embraced for the last eight years and plans to continue for the next four. These policies didn’t work then, they won’t work now, and I’m running for President to end them. We need to grow our economy by creating jobs, providing tax relief for middle class families, and helping people stay in their homes, and that is exactly what I will do as President,” said Senator Barack Obama.
Feeds: 



COMMENTS (3)
A good dose of (peace-time) Keynsianism! Just what the doctor ordered. The money should be spent as Van Jones, the Oaklanc (Ca) "greentrepeneur" and social advocate/activist/organizer proposes.
Never heard of Van Jones? Open your eyes, folks, cuz he's onto sumpin big here.
Posted by: woody | October 30, 2008 12:07 PM
Why don't we bring the cap gains tax rate down to zero? That should take care of this so-called "recession."
Posted by: Cahnman | October 30, 2008 12:35 PM
With the news that our economy is now contracting -- for the first time since 1991
It's the first time consumer spending has contracted since 1991. I don't think it's the first time the GDP has contracted since then.
Posted by: Glenn | October 30, 2008 1:34 PM