RSS Feeds Feeds: Articles | Issues
Articles About TAP Subscribe Donate
TAPPED  |  Beat the Press

Remember Me
Forgot your password?

The symbol identifies content for paid subscribers only.


 



The group blog of The American Prospect

MORE WOMEN MODERATORS, PLEASE.

I was IMing with a staffer for one of the non-Hillary Clinton campaigns who was annoyed by the way Clinton is talking about gender in the wake of Tuesday night's debate, which featured Clinton as the lone woman facing six male competitors and two male questioners, when it occurred to me that there would be a very easy way to change the dynamic so that there's not so much focus on Clinton's gender: There should be some women moderating these debates.

It's problematic that of the six official Democratic National Committee-sanctioned debates, only the final one, on Dec. 10, will feature a female moderator, and then only as part of a team. This sets up a disquieting dynamic for female Democratic viewers, and also sets up a visual that benefits Clinton by showcasing her status as a pioneer in a man's world. Television is the most-gender integrated form of media we have, because women watch more television than men (though not perhaps more political debates), and because it just looks wrong to them in this day and age to be presented with the visual of an all male world. (No one notices in print journalism.)

Unfortunately, mainstream nightly news programs have a ways to go when it comes to featuring women as the anchor, and none of the Sunday political talk shows (except the all-female To The Contrary) is hosted by a woman. Hence, the moderators for the six DNC-sanctioned debates:

  • Anderson Cooper (July 23, 2007: YouTube/Google and CNN in Charleston, SC)
  • George Stephanopoulous (August 19, 2007: ABC in Des Moines, IA)
  • Tim Russert (September 26, 2007: NBC News/MSNBC in Hanover, NH)
  • Tim Russert and Brian Williams (October 30, 2007: NBC News/MSNBC in Philadelphia, PA)
  • Wolf Blitzer November 15, 2007: CNN in Las Vegas, NV
  • Bob Schieffer and Katie Couric (December 10, 2007: CBS in Los Angeles, CA)

That's just 12.5 percent women moderators (I counted Russert twice since he moderated twice).* If the DNC didn't want to set up a dynamic that reinforced Clinton's message to women primary voters, it could have put some pressure on the media institutions it was partnering with to send some female moderators to help run the debates. It's likely too late for any changes now, but this is the kind of thing worth thinking about in the future.

* Allison King of New England Cable News posed a few questions from New England locals during the latter part of Sept. 26 NBC debate, and there were, obviously, many questions from women during the YouTube debate. But the moderators for the debates were 87.5 percent male -- a gender breakdown that's even worse than the Senate!

--Garance Franke-Ruta



COMMENTS

Gwen Ifill did a fine job moderating the vice-presidential debate in 2004 and would be an obvious candidate for this.

Very rational solution to what shouldn't be a problem.

As a woman, I truly resent a woman setting herself up as the strongest, most viable, most experienced and at the first sign of even minor trouble, hides behind her (and my) gender as a change the subject.

It does nothing but denegrade me and my hard work and accomplishments.

Take the distraction away by installing the best women journalists...course then she'll take tough questions as catty or some other nonsense.

The biggest problem with that list of moderators isn't the number of dicks, it's the number of dickheads.

Would you rather see Michelle Malkin and Ann Coulter in there?

Maria Bartiromo did a good job co-moderating that one GOP debate.

"Maria Bartiromo did a good job co-moderating that one GOP debate."

She did. She had decent questions, they had the same answer (albeit the one CNBC wants to hear). She was practically begging them to concede that people thought things weren't so great on Main Street, and they wouldn't budge an inch. I guess Democrats would concede that. I wonder if she'd press them on what they propose to do.

Apparently there is a CNBC Democratic debate, late in November.

Post a comment


Search TAPPED for:

Archives

About TAPPED

TAPPED, the Prospect's award-winning group blog, is a link-intensive collection of musings, ramblings, opinions and other assorted writing on the political developments of the day. See a list of our contributors.

| RSS | Twitter


Renew your print subscription or e-subscription.
Get an e-subscription for $14.95.
Give the gift of political insight. Send The American Prospect to a friend.
Change your email address or street address.
YES! I want to receive The American Prospect
— the essential source for progressive ideas.
Explore The American Prospect's award-winning investigative journalism and provocative essays in a free trial issue. Continue receiving The American Prospect at only $19.95 for a one-year subscription - a savings of 60% off the newsstand price!
First Name
Last Name
Address 1
Address 2
City
State
ZIP     
Email

Should you decide not to continue receiving the magazine after the initial free issue, simply write "cancel" on the invoice and you will not be billed.

© 2009 by The American Prospect, Inc.  |  Privacy Policy  |  Permissions and Reprints